So, I effed up and bought Catalina dressing instead of Russian for a recipe, and I don't have time to run to the store. Thousand Island dressing [moved from Home Cooking] discussion from the Chowhound General Discussion, Salad Dressing food community. Russian dressing is made with a mayonnaise-ketchup base, often livened up with pickle relish, Worcestershire sauce, prepared horseradish, and lemon juice and seasoned with paprika, onion … ... Richard_in_Texas Dec 20, 2014 09:38 AM Apparently Wishbone has two different dressings they have called Wishbone. I havent ever tasted catalina … I have a recipe for catalina chicken (which calls for catalina dressing). It's for a chicken sweet and sour sauce if … Here is the one that is also known as Catalina. Do you think it will taste the same. All I have is russian dressing. From a rich and creamy dressing to accompany a filling dinner salad like Caesar to a light and refreshing balsamic vinaigrette for a springy mixed green salad, there's a dressing for everyone's … Can it be used in it's place, or is that disgusting? Read page 5 of the Russian vs. I prefer russian over catalina just because it doesnt have red dye 40 in it and we have kids eating it.