May 4, 2011. Pour around 2 tbsp worth of the mixture onto a wax paper or cookie sheet and press to form a small disc. Add melted ingredients and the flax seed mix to the dry mixture and mix on medium speed until just combined and then add the egg. Make sure to use creamy peanut butter. Healthy Peanut Butter Cookies This is such a great recipe – you will need to take a little time to rest the batter, but the end result is well worth the wait. Mix oats, baking soda, fenugreek, cinnamon, baking powder, yeast, salt and nuts together in a bowl.Blend together banana, eggs, and coconut oil until getting a smooth texture. Mix well to form a cookie dough. Healthy and... healthy peanut butter cookies. You can make a batch ahead of time and just grab one whenever you need one. While this recipe for healthy peanut butter cookies is gluten-free, if you’re strict in that regard, be sure to use certified gluten-free oats here (but I’m sure you know that). How I converted the typical oat and peanut butter cookie into an amazing healthy vegan lactation cookie powerhouse! Mix the dry and wet ingredients with the hands. These peanut butter cookies are great when you need a quick healthy snack. Peanut Butter; Maple Syrup; Oat Flour, Coconut Flour or Superfine Almond Flour; Peanut Butter. In a small saucepan melt together butter, peanut butter and honey on low heat until combined and allow to cool slightly. Ingredients. My ULTIMATE favorite cookies are “Wacky No Bake Cookies” AKA Oatmeal Chocolate, Peanut Butter cookies. These cookies aren’t the most sturdy cookies out there as the main ingredient is peanut butter.