The ideal way to reheat pizza is obviously to put it in the oven. How soggy it gets. Place on paper plate in microwave. Remove pizza from plastic wrap. Cook on High for 3 minutes, 30 seconds. There’s nothing wrong with cooking it in the Microwave, but (here’s your warning) you are definitely not going to get the crispy-crust you would from the oven – it’s more like soft French bread (which… Remove pizza from overwrap before cooking. PRODUCT MUST BE COOKED THOROUGHLY TO 160℉ FOR FOOD SAFETY AND QUALITY. Spray the browning pan lightly with oil and preheat it in your microwave for 2 to 3 minutes, as directed by the manufacturer. the time you want one pizza pop to be in is for around 1 minute or 1 minute 30 seconds. To cook your pizza in a microwave, prepare your browning plate. For those of you who love those great slices of pizza goodness, you know Stouffer’s doesn’t give straight Microwave directions. DO NOT ALLOW PIZZA TO THAW. *Quicknote if you dont want a mess in your microwave you can put a napkin or paper towel over the pizza pop to stop the pizza pops inside from exploding like they are known for. But just sticking it in the microwave can produce a brittle, tooth-shattering crust. You have a meal. If you used the wrapped cubes, just discard the wrapping and put the sugar cubes in the sugar bowl for later. Contrary to popular belief, it is possible to microwave food without ruining it —and that includes pizza. MICROWAVE COOKING INSTRUCTIONS. The next day, that cold pizza really seems like a gift. ), and after taking it out of the oven remove the sugar cubes (which will probably be stuck to the base of the pizza). Once it's preheated, carefully place your pizza dough on the pan. DO NOT EAT PIZZA WITHOUT COOKING. Microwave a thin crust for 2 minutes and a thicker crust for 3 to 4 minutes. Then microwave the pizza for a few minutes (trial & error! If i have a slice of pizza in the fridge how long should i put it in the microwave All ya gotta do is stick it in the microwave and bam! But the worst part about trying to reheat pizza in the microwave?